What You Should Know About Foreclosure Taxation in 2024

Foreclosure is already stressful, but foreclosure taxation rules can take homeowners by surprise.

When the IRS—the U.S. government agency responsible for collecting taxes and enforcing tax laws—treats a foreclosure as a “sale,” the resulting financial impact can ripple into tax season with significant consequences.

Whether you’re dealing with tax implications of foreclosure, loan forgiveness, or property losses, knowing how these situations affect your taxes in 2024 is crucial.

This guide breaks down everything you need to know, helping you make informed decisions and avoid unnecessary tax burdens.

If you want to skip the complexities of foreclosure taxation altogether and avoid the lengthy foreclosure process, consider selling your home for cash in as little as seven days.

While selling your home may still have tax implications, Fantastic Homes, trusted cash home buyers in the Chicagoland area, can provide you with an easy, hassle-free solution.

Contact us today for a no-obligation cash offer!

Understanding Foreclosure and Its Tax Implications

Foreclosure is the legal process where a lender takes ownership of a property because the borrower defaults on mortgage payments. 

It doesn’t just mean losing your home—it also comes with foreclosure tax implications that the IRS treats as a sale of property.

This classification often results in either capital gains or losses, or cancellation of debt (COD) income—both of which can significantly impact your income taxes, as we’ll explore below.

What Is a Foreclosure?

A foreclosure happens when a borrower can no longer keep up with mortgage payments, and the lender reclaims the property.

While this seems straightforward, the IRS’s treatment of the event as a “sale” means there are significant tax consequences to consider.

Types of Foreclosure: Judicial vs. Non-Judicial

There are two main types of foreclosure: judicial and non-judicial.

Judicial foreclosures involve court intervention, which is required in Illinois and many other states. Non-judicial foreclosures, on the other hand, bypass the courts but follow strict state guidelines.

Understanding which process applies to you is essential because the type of foreclosure may affect your foreclosure taxation outcome.

How the IRS Treats a Foreclosure as a Sale

For tax purposes, the IRS treats a foreclosure like you’ve sold your home, even though you didn’t actually sell it on the open market.

This means the IRS calculates whether you’ve made a profit (capital gains) or experienced forgiven debt (cancellation of debt, or COD income) based on the ‘sale price’ of the property.

The ‘sale price‘ isn’t straightforward—it depends on whether your mortgage is a recourse loan or a non-recourse loan, which are two types of loans with very different legal and tax implications:

Recourse Loan

If you have a recourse loan, the lender has the legal right to pursue you for any remaining balance on the loan after the foreclosure, meaning you could owe money even after losing the property.

For example, if you owed $300,000 but the property was sold or valued at $250,000 during foreclosure, the lender could demand the remaining $50,000 from you. For tax purposes, the ‘sale price’ used to calculate capital gains is the lesser of the loan balance or the fair market value (FMV) of the property—$250,000 in this case.

Additionally, if the lender forgives any part of the debt, such as the $50,000 in this example, that forgiven amount is considered COD income and may be taxable.

Non-Recourse Loan

With a non-recourse loan, the lender cannot pursue you for any remaining balance after they reclaim the property. The foreclosure is the end of the financial relationship. Here, the ‘sale price’ is considered the full loan balance, not the FMV of the property, which would be $300,000.

Because the lender has no legal recourse to demand additional payment, there’s no COD income. However, you may still face capital gains or losses based on the difference between the loan balance (the ‘sale price’) and your adjusted basis in the property.

The adjusted basis is essentially what you’ve invested in the property—it’s the original purchase price plus the cost of any significant improvements (like a new roof or kitchen renovation), minus any depreciation (if the property was rented out or used for business purposes).

This distinction is critical because it affects what the IRS considers taxable. With recourse loans, you could end up being taxed on COD income and potentially a capital gain.

With non-recourse loans, you’re only taxed on capital gains or losses, which simplifies things but may still carry financial consequences.

Understanding how this works is key to preparing for how foreclosure affects your income tax return.

What Is Cancellation of Debt (COD) Income?

Cancellation of debt (COD) income occurs when a lender forgives part or all of your mortgage debt during foreclosure. This forgiven debt is often treated as taxable income.

When Does COD Income Occur?

COD income arises when the lender forgives debt that exceeds the value of the property.

For example, if you owed $300,000 but the home’s value was only $250,000 at foreclosure, the $50,000 difference could be treated as COD income.

Why COD Income Is Considered Taxable

The IRS considers forgiven debt as income because it increases your net worth. While it may feel unfair, understanding this rule helps you prepare for any unexpected tax bills.

Examples of COD Income in Foreclosure

If you undergo a deed in lieu of foreclosure tax implications scenario, you may still face COD income.

A deed in lieu of foreclosure is an agreement where the borrower voluntarily transfers ownership of their property directly to the lender in exchange for being released from the mortgage debt. While this avoids the lengthy foreclosure process and potentially saves the borrower from further legal action, the lender may forgive any remaining balance on the loan.

For example, if the lender forgives $100,000 as part of this arrangement, that forgiven amount may be taxed as ordinary income—unless exclusions apply, such as insolvency (when your total debts exceed your total assets, making you financially unable to pay) or the principal residence exclusion (a tax rule that allows forgiven debt on your main home to be excluded from taxable income, up to $750,000).

Recourse vs. Non-Recourse Loans and Their Tax Impact

Your loan type—recourse or non-recourse—determines whether COD income or capital gains apply after foreclosure.

Tax Treatment of Recourse Loans

With recourse loans, lenders can pursue the borrower for the remaining balance after foreclosure. The foreclosure tax implications here include potential COD income and capital gains.

Tax Treatment of Non-Recourse Loans

In a non-recourse loan, the lender’s only remedy is to take the property. No COD income arises, and the outstanding loan balance becomes the “sale price” for tax purposes.

How Loan Types Affect Gain, Loss, and COD Income

Recourse loans often involve both capital gains and COD income, while non-recourse loans simplify things by focusing only on capital gains or losses. Understanding these distinctions is key to preparing for foreclosure taxation.

Also Read: What Is Delinquent Tax? Here’s What It Means for Your Home

Calculating Capital Gains and Losses on a Foreclosure

Foreclosures can also result in capital gains or losses, depending on the property’s value and your adjusted basis.

Determining Your Property’s Adjusted Basis

Your adjusted basis is the original purchase price, plus improvements, minus any depreciation. Calculating this correctly is crucial for determining whether you owe tax on foreclosure homes.

How Fair Market Value (FMV) Affects the Sale Price

For recourse loans, the IRS uses the fair market value (FMV) of the property as the sale price. For non-recourse loans, the loan balance itself becomes the sale price.

Why Personal Residence Losses Are Not Deductible

If your home’s value has decreased and you incur a loss from foreclosure, you cannot deduct that loss because personal residence losses are not tax-deductible.

Key Exclusions to Avoid Tax on COD Income

Thankfully, there are exclusions that can protect homeowners from being taxed on COD income.

Insolvency Exclusion

If your total debts exceed your assets (you’re insolvent), you can exclude some or all COD income. This is a critical relief option for struggling homeowners.

Bankruptcy Exclusion

Debts discharged through bankruptcy are not taxable. If you faced foreclosure during bankruptcy, this exclusion eliminates COD income.

Qualified Principal Residence Debt Exclusion

The IRS allows exclusions for canceled mortgage debt on your primary residence, up to $750,000.

Forms You Need for Reporting Foreclosure on Your Taxes

When foreclosure happens, lenders will send you specific IRS forms that must be reported on your tax return.

Understanding Form 1099-C: Cancellation of Debt

Form 1099-C reports the amount of canceled debt and is sent to both you and the IRS if the forgiven amount is $600 or more.

This form is essential for understanding your foreclosure taxation obligations because the amount listed may be considered taxable income unless you qualify for exclusions, such as insolvency or the principal residence exclusion, as discussed above.

Form 1099-A: Acquisition or Abandonment of Secured Property

Form 1099-A provides important details about the foreclosure sale, including the outstanding loan balance, the fair market value (FMV) of the property, and the date of acquisition or abandonment.

Acquisition refers to when the lender takes ownership of the property after the foreclosure, while abandonment means the borrower has relinquished possession of the property, often before the formal foreclosure process is complete.

This form helps you and the IRS calculate any potential capital gains or losses, as well as determine whether you may have cancellation of debt (COD) income. It is often used alongside Form 1099-C for tax reporting purposes.

How to Use IRS Form 982 for COD Exclusions

Form 982 allows you to claim exclusions, such as insolvency (when your total debts exceed your total assets) or bankruptcy (debts discharged through a legal bankruptcy proceeding), to reduce or eliminate taxable cancellation of debt (COD) income.

Foreclosure Tax Rules for Primary Residences vs. Investment Properties

Different rules apply when foreclosure involves your primary home versus an investment property.

Rules for Primary Residences and Capital Gains Exclusion

If you sell your primary home, you might not have to pay taxes on up to $250,000 of profit from the sale if you’re single, or up to $500,000 if you’re married and file taxes jointly.

However, to qualify for this tax break, you must meet the ownership and use tests:

• Ownership Test: You must have owned the home for at least 2 years out of the last 5 years before the sale.
• Use Test: The home must have been your main place of living (primary residence) for at least 2 years out of those 5 years.

If you meet both conditions, the profit from the sale within those limits is excluded from your taxable income. This exclusion can apply even if the home was foreclosed, as long as these tests are satisfied.

How Foreclosures on Investment Properties Are Taxed

For investment properties, losses may be deductible, but capital gains and COD income are still taxable. This is critical for those concerned about foreclosure on rental property tax implications.

Short Sales vs. Foreclosures: Tax Differences

Short sales are often an alternative to foreclosure, but they come with their own tax implications.

What Is a Short Sale?

A short sale occurs when you sell your home for less than what you owe on the mortgage, with lender approval.

Tax Treatment of Short Sales Compared to Foreclosures

Short sales may still trigger COD income, but they can be less damaging than a foreclosure because they involve working with the lender to sell the property, avoiding the legal process of foreclosure.

This typically has a smaller impact on your credit score and can result in less forgiven debt, leading to lower potential taxes from COD income.

When a Short Sale Might Be a Better Option

Short sales can minimize financial damage and tax exposure, making them a better option when the property’s value is less than the mortgage balance and the lender agrees to the sale.

Homeowners may qualify if they demonstrate financial hardship, such as job loss or significant medical expenses.

How State Laws Impact Foreclosure Taxation

State laws, especially regarding deficiency judgments (court orders requiring borrowers to pay the remaining balance if a foreclosure sale doesn’t cover the mortgage), impact how foreclosures play out financially and legally.

Deficiency Judgments in Illinois and the Midwest

States like Illinois allow lenders to pursue deficiency judgments, meaning you could still owe money after foreclosure.

State-Specific Rules for COD Income and Property Sales

Each state has unique rules for tax implications of foreclosure, so homeowners should understand their state laws or consult a professional.

Steps to Minimize Your Tax Burden During a Foreclosure

Avoid unnecessary taxes by taking the following steps.

Consulting a Tax Professional

A tax professional can ensure you report correctly and claim all exclusions available.

Negotiating Debt Forgiveness Terms with Your Lender

Work with your lender to reduce COD income or negotiate better terms.

Keeping Proper Documentation for IRS Compliance

Save all foreclosure-related documents, including Forms 1099-C and 1099-A, to ensure accurate reporting.

How Fantastic Homes Can Help You Avoid Foreclosure Stress

At Fantastic Homes, your trusted real estate agent in Chicago, we help you avoid the stress of foreclosure by offering a fast, all-cash solution to sell your home quickly.

While selling your home may still come with certain tax considerations, our straightforward process simplifies the sale, saving you time and eliminating unnecessary complications.

Sell Your Home Fast for Cash, “As-Is”

You don’t need to make repairs or wait months—sell your home quickly, in any condition, in as little as seven days.

Avoid Repairs, Agent Fees, and Closing Costs

We cover all closing costs, eliminating agent fees and out-of-pocket expenses.

Why Homeowners Trust Fantastic Homes in Chicagoland

As a trusted, family-owned business, we’ve helped countless homeowners through difficult situations like foreclosure.

Contact Fantastic Homes Today for a Hassle-Free Solution to Foreclosure

If you’re facing foreclosure, don’t wait.

Contact us today for a quick, stress-free solution to sell your home for cash..

Let us help you move forward!